The Company We Keep is not just your average café — it’s a multifaceted establishment born from the vision of industry mavens Jenn Hornak and Nika Mistruzzi. Drawing on their expertise in sommelier work and baking, they’ve created a space that effortlessly shifts from pantry and café to wine bar and restaurant, all while serving as a vibrant venue for pop-up events.
Walking into the space is like stepping into a cosy kitchen with friends. Hornak and Mistruzzi wanted a place where guests could relax, connect and enjoy homemade food, and they’ve done just that. From Mistruzzi’s delicious pies made with seasonal fruits to Hornak’s thoughtfully chosen wines, everything reflects a commitment to quality and authenticity.
But it’s not just about the food — it’s about the experience. The café buzzes with life, hosting everything from culinary pop-ups to live music nights. And with partnerships with local suppliers and industry friends, every product on the menu is a testament to the power of collaboration.
“We both wanted to open a café that fostered a sense of creativity and community,” say the owners.
The support of family and friends has played a crucial role in our business journey. They have been instrumental not only in designing and decorating the space but also in contributing to the daily operations.
“We are so lucky to have Nika’s mother-in-law, Ersilia, work at the shop every Saturday. She brings such beautiful energy to the team, and we love learning from her,” say Hornak and Mistruzzi. “Jenn’s mom, Roberta, is always helping us with repairs and upkeep; we couldn’t thank her enough. Roberta and Jenn’s stepdad, Jack, also make custom wooden cutting boards that we sell at the shop.”
The evening program enhances the experience with wine flights, cider, beer and cocktails, complemented by small plates of charcuterie and savoury snacks. And with a happy hour that starts at 2:oo p.m. daily complete with $5 beers and $7 glasses of wine, the festivities can begin early.
Looking ahead, guests can expect even more goodness on the horizon. With plans to expand their patio space, enhance their menu offerings and host a variety of events and collaborations, this café’s journey is just beginning.
In a world of fast dining, The Company We Keep offers a refreshing reminder: good food and company make life meaningful.
The Company We Keep is located at 634 St. Clair Ave. W.